#supernatural | make-me-imagine (2024)

Scenario Prompts:Feb 22 E: + Feb 18 E: Lucifer is protective of you because he is in love with you + Lucifer Confesses he is in love with you, because he is in love with you.Requested by: Two Separate(?) Anons

Premise: Lucifer has protected and saved you multiple times in the past; when you are finally alone with him you get the chance to ask him why.

Pairing: Lucifer x Gen!Neutral Reader

Triggers:Fighting, Blood, injuries, monster death, etc.

Words:3k (told you it was long)

Note: I have not seen the last 3-4 seasons of Supernatural. So this is based in a world were Lucifer is like Crowley; he’s a“bad guy” that shows up to help, and annoy Sam and Dean occasionally and what not.

See about Scenario Prompt Requests: here

You eyed the angel from the corner of your eye as he leaned against the doorway, picking at his nails. Walking across the room and stopping next to Dean you spoke quietly to him“Why is he here again exactly?”

He glanced over at Lucifer before responding“No idea, but I guess it’s better to have an eye on him than to have no idea where he is and what he’s up too.”

You looked over at Lucifer, your heart skipping a beat when you see that he is now staring at you. Looking back at Dean you muttered“If you say so.”

Turning at the sound of the door, Sam walks in with a duffel bag in hand“Hey, so I didn’t-” he stops in his tracks when he spots Lucifer“What the hell are you doing here?” he asked before looking at you and Dean.

Lucifer shrugged“Bored.” he said plainly before looking back at you and Dean“But it’s better that I’m here right? Rather than you having no idea where I am or what I’m up too.” he repeated Dean’s own words back to him with a slight smirk on his face.

Sam let out an annoyed sigh before walking to the table and putting down the duffel bag“Anyways, what I was saying was that I didn’t find any trace of the witches in town, so they must be hiding out outside of town. If we can figure out where then we can get them by surprise.”

“I wouldn’t be so sure about that one Sammy.” Lucifer said as he peaked out the curtained window.

“Yeah, and why’s that?” Sam asked with disdain.

“Because I’m pretty sure they already know you’re here.” He said as he straightened up, just as the door blasted in making you all jump and fall into a defensive stance.

You reached for the knife in your belt, leaving your hand on it in preparation as you watched three older women and a man walk into the room. They must have followed Sam back here. Lucifer slowly rounded the side of the room until he was on the same side as you. You stared at him in confusion as he stepped in front of you, getting in your way.

“Well well, to what do we owe the honor of having the Winchesters in our humble little town?” One of the women asked, a scornful look on her face before she looked at Lucifer and then saw you behind him“And I don’t believe I know either of you.”

Lucifer took a step forward“What a shame, and here I thought I was famous.” he said with a sarcastic tone in his voice“Lucifer, nice to meet you.”

The witches looked at each other before smiling“Yeah right” one of the younger witches said with a scoff“As if Lucifer would be with the Winchesters.”

Lucifer shrugged“We’re working on our problems” he looked back at Sam. “Right Sammy?”Sam clenched his jaw in annoyance before looking back at the witches.

“Then you’re a traitor” one of the witches said with anger before he raised his hand, shooting out a fire ball at Lucifer and you.

Lucifer quickly reached his arm back grabbing and pushing you out of the way before he lunged towards the witch, gripping him on the shoulder and staring into his eyes“Well that was dramatic. And quite stupid honestly.”

You watched as the witch began to crumple to the ground as his skin began to burn, landing on the floor lifeless. You were surprised by this, having thought Lucifer lost most of his stronger powers.

One of the other witches yelled in anger, gaining your attention once again. You and Dean lunged forward and attacked the other witches with your iron blades. Sam took out his gun and fired his gun at one of the witches, killing them immediately.